NZ's 'worst economic decision ever' – revisited

Brian Gaynor looked at the consequences of abolishing the NZ Superannuation Scheme. (Image: BusinessDesk)

Sat, 10 Sep 2022

Fund manager and business columnist, the late Brian Gaynor, called it a dreadful decision – possibly the worst ever made by a New Zealand government.In December 1975, the new National government led by Robert Muldoon abolished the 37-week-old compulsory New Zealand Superannuation Scheme, introduced by the previous Labour government.At the time there was just $40 million in the scheme.But – as New Zealanders were quick to recognise last week when the government tried to apply GST to KiwiSaver fees – small sums grow exponentiall...

Subscribe to BusinessDesk

Stay informed on business, government and financial developments across New Zealand.

Deeply researched, twice-edited and fact-checked news
Annual subscribers also receive a complimentary subscription to The Wall Street Journal
Personalised email news alerts, plus gift up to 5 stories a month to non-subscribers

You can cancel anytime with two clicks, an email or a phone call.
Find out more.

We are serious about journalism.

Name {{ registerForm.errors.get('name') }}

Email address {{ registerForm.errors.get('email') }}

Phone Number {{ registerForm.errors.get('phone') }}

Job Title {{ registerForm.errors.get('title') }}

Password Minimum password length of 8 characters.
Require at least one upper and lowercase, numeric, and special character. {{ registerForm.errors.get('password') }}

Repeat password {{ registerForm.errors.get('password_confirmation') }}

We had trouble validating your card. It's possible your card provider is preventing us from charging the card. Please contact your card provider or customer support.

Credit Card

Cardholder's name

{{ __(plans[index].name) | capitalize }} {{ plans[index].attributes.old_price | currency }} {{ plans[index].price | currency }}

All subscriptions auto renew but are easy to cancel.

I Accept The Terms Of Service

{{ registerForm.errors.get('terms') }}

Tax: {{ taxAmount(selectedPlan) | currency }}

Total Price Including Tax: {{ priceWithTax(selectedPlan) | currency }} {{ selectedPlan.type == 'user' && spark.chargesUsersPerSeat ? '/ '+ spark.seatName : '' }} {{ selectedPlan.type == 'user' && spark.chargesUsersPerTeam ? '/ '+ __('teams.team') : '' }} / {{ __(selectedPlan.interval) | capitalize }}

Markets Market Close

Infratil, Mainfreight hit by US news flow; NZX down 2.3%

The S&P/NZX 50 fell 2.33% to 11,836.69 points.

Gregor Thompson 5:55pm

Markets

ACC slams CDL's new offer for Millennium & Copthorne shares

The shares lifted 27% on the revised offer.

Rebecca Howard 5:15pm

ACC slams CDL's new offer for Millennium & Copthorne shares

Infrastructure

NZTA moves forward with Bay of Plenty highway

Bishop promises freight and housing perks from $3b roading project.

Oliver Lewis 4:40pm

NZTA moves forward with Bay of Plenty highway

Sponsored

Bayleys Total Property Issue 3 out now

Backed by Bayleys’ national strength and global reach

Bayleys

Sponsored

Go beyond reporting zero emissions

Clean energy that helps businesses and communities thrive

Meridian Energy

More Finance

Finance

FNZ extends controversial catch-up offer

Fintech FNZ has extended its deadline for “catch-up” equity offers, as employee shareholders say discontent grows.In March, the global fintech offered its class B shareholders a “catch-up” offer after it revealed their holdings could be massively diluted following its August capi...

Victoria Young 16 Apr 2025