Why doesn’t the Treasury just do its own costings on election promises?

Why doesn’t the Treasury just do its own costings on election promises?
Michael Cullen accused then-minister of finance Ruth Richardson of releasing a “screed of lies”. (Image: Getty)
Jem Traylen
Arguments over the cost of National’s election promises dominated the first few weeks of the campaign. With both main parties releasing their fiscal packages this week, that is probably just an entrée for what will come.So, why can’t we rely on the experts at the Treasury to shed some light on all this policy costing palaver?For the answer, we need to flashback to the 1993 election when it was Labour’s policy costings that everyone was arguing about.At that time, the Treasury did provide costings of election promises wh...

More Policy

'There are some firms in NZ I won’t touch'
Policy

'There are some firms in NZ I won’t touch'

Adam Feeley on the reluctance to call out poor performers in NZ infrastructure sector.

Oliver Lewis 30 Jun 2025
Govt mandates high-rise zoning around key CRL stations
Policy

Govt mandates high-rise zoning around key CRL stations

Auckland Council will need to provide for building heights of at least 10-15 storeys.

Oliver Lewis 25 Jun 2025
Infrastructure Plan floats higher health, electricity spend
Policy

Infrastructure Plan floats higher health, electricity spend

Draft plan identifies priority projects and recommends transport system reform.

Oliver Lewis 25 Jun 2025
Infrastructure plan: 17 projects made it, 31 missed out
Policy

Infrastructure plan: 17 projects made it, 31 missed out

Rail, prison and ferry terminal projects excluded from infrastructure priority list.

Oliver Lewis 25 Jun 2025